MEDIA RELEASE
26 April, 2001
NZ NEEDS SUPERANNUATION POLICY THAT INTEGRATES
PUBLIC AND PRIVATE EFFORTS
The Investment Savings and Insurance Association expressed some
support for the New Zealand Superannuation Bill when it presented its submission to
Parliament’s Finance and Expenditure Select Committee this afternoon in Wellington.
The ISI submission calls, however, for wider consideration of the
total retirement planning issue.
"The ISI strongly urges that New Zealand Superannuation is
considered as part of an integrated framework for public and private provision for
retirement. We call on the political leaders to develop a comprehensive plan for the
public and private provision of retirement income. We should not be considering the public
provision through New Zealand Superannuation in isolation to essential private
efforts," said ISI Chief Executive, Vance Arkinstall.
"Pre-funding and changes to New Zealand Superannuation
should be considered as only one part of a 3 tier framework that integrates public and
private provision, Mr Arkinstall says. This is in line with World Bank recommendations.
New Zealand Superannuation represents the first tier, providing
the safety net of a basic, no frills, income in retirement. Certainty of a safety net is
essential, especially for those who are unable to save."
"The second tier of the framework outlined in the ISI
submission is to encourage work-based savings through employer sponsored superannuation
plans. There is no doubt that retirement savings deducted directly from salary is the most
effective means to save," says Mr Arkinstall.
Mr Arkinstall also stated that "work-based savings must be
simplified with reduced compliance requirements for employers. Additionally, work-based
savings would be more attractive if contributions were made from pre-tax earnings."
"New Zealand needs to seriously consider compulsory
work-based savings as part of the overall formula to solve New Zealand’s low savings
rate. We accept that compulsion is fraught with political difficulties but it is an
effective part of retirement planning overseas and independent surveys indicate a high
level of support," said Mr Arkinstall.
The third tier of the recommended framework is private voluntary
saving.
"We have grave concerns that pre-funding is viewed by many
individuals as providing a total solution to adequate income in retirement. This is
certainly not the case," said Mr Arkinstall.
"Pre-funding of New Zealand Superannuation on its own is not
the answer and New Zealand Superannuation will not provide sufficient income for those New
Zealanders who want more than a basic lifestyle in retirement.
Mr Arkinstall says that "We are all living longer, we will
spend many more years in retirement than our parents and we will live a more active and
demanding lifestyle. New Zealand Superannuation simply will not fund that lifestyle at
anything other than the basic level. Individuals must see New Zealand Superannuation as a
foundation which they should supplement with private savings."
"The ISI is also concerned that people may be being misled
by the current method of defining New Zealand Superannuation as 65% of the average weekly
wage. That is the level that applies to a married couple, but individuals will receive
only approximately 39% of the average weekly wage. We strongly encourage a change that
describes NZS at the individual level. New Zealanders will realise that they will not be
able to achieve their retirement lifestyle ambitions from NZS alone."
"Government and politicians must quickly move to establish
an environment that encourages savings in this country. There is no doubt that private
savings will play an important role in strengthening the economy. There is also no doubt
that presented with clear direction and certainty on savings policy and a savings friendly
environment, New Zealanders will respond positively", said Mr Arkinstall.
Ends
Vance Arkinstall
Chief Executive
ISI
